Are you trying to match the camera, or just get lensboards that work? If the latter, it probably doesn't matter too much as long as you don't use a transparent wood...
My wife has made several using cherry thinstock. The hard part is apparently the hole, especially for larger shutters where even if you have a big enough hole bit, it's hard to get a good place to clamp. If you have a planer, it wouldn't be imperative to start with thinstock, which would open the door to using all sorts of random interesting woods. Cocobolo lensboards, anyone?
-NT