I've also got some undiluted Ilford Rapid Fixer, first opened about a year ago, that's giving a cloudy precipitate when prepared to 1+4. The working fixer has also been very aggressive at turning weird colours (first pink with RPX 25, then a grey after some tri-x and tmy) which the previous batch never did, even at the point where it wasn't completely fixing tri-x after 5 minutes. There's also a crusty line of... something... in the storage bottle.
Never knew I'd have to buy fixer yearly
The point about false economies is definitely correct. That being said, I'm going to play this one for sport and see what long-in-the-tooth fixer ends up doing, eventually-- re-fixing isn't such a big deal as xtol gone off.