- Joined
- Jul 14, 2011
- Messages
- 13,932
- Format
- 8x10 Format
That may very well be correct, but makes no sense at all to me. Why would professionals use mainly slide film? I can think of very few applications where the customer would ask for slide film.
For what it is worth I feel that instead of it being about cameras' different metering systems it maybe harks back to a variation on a statement that I have seen before on Photrio which is raging now in this thread that some cameras' metering was specifically designed for correct exposure for slide film rather than negative film. If I recall correctly this was alleged to be true for the meter in an F5
pentaxuser
But anything that is really worth doing is hard and inconvenient. The easy isn't worth bothering with.
Have you ever seen that described in any sales material or user guides? I’d expect it to either be a marketing boast or in the user manual yet I’ve never noticed such a claim. No offense to anyone believing this, but it sounds to me like a hypothetical that has been repeated a lot in photo forums with no factual foundation clearly stated. I’d love to be “proven” wrong. Recollection and “belief/feel” are sometimes error-prone.
Buy some cameras and test it for yourself. Good excuse to exercise GAS.
I didn’t make the claim; I believe you did. I have no GAS nor any interest in proving or disproving the claims made by others. If you can’t support your claim other than repeating that you are correct, that’s fine with me. My experience with both film types and both camera types “explains” that concept differently. Peace, out.
I have the information somewhere.If I find it I'll post it. I saw it either in a service manual or a technical article from Pop Photo years ago.
It really doesn't matter because I only shoot film now for fun,anything for publication is digital.
AI Overview
Yes, there are a few cameras designed for transparency film, including:
- Ricoh Xobbox: A limited edition, transparent, point-and-shoot camera made in 1993. It has a 35mm lens, fixed focus, and a shutter speed of 1/125 of a second.
- To Be Continued (TBC) Transparent Camera: A reusable film camera with a translucent PETG body that allows you to see the camera's mechanisms.
- Klutz Transparent Green 35mm Point and Shoot Film Camera: A transparent green 35mm point and shoot film camera.
Well, I wouldn't trust just anything Pop Photo published, if in fact it did say that; it was hardly a technical or pro journal. "Pop"- anything magazines had to be taken with a grain of salt.
I agree that it doesn't matter (especially to you at this point, it seems) yet its an interesting topic. After using 127 box cameras, I started with Minolta SRT-102, which had a interesting metering system - two CDS cells to better manage scene contrast... like a 2-element matrix metering situation. Then to Nikkormat FT-3 and Nikon F-3, Both center-weighted meters, like your XG-1. All of which benefit all types of film when shooting in automatic mode. I can imagine reviews of cameras with these types of meters, and even moreso with the mulitple matrix metering that followed, to off-handedly state that it really helps improve performance with E-6 transparencies. That may be part of a driving requirement by the manufacturer, but the bigger part probably was to enhance exposure accuracy with ALL films to be used. Even Ken Rockwell in his Nikon F5 review just states the technical specifications and the overall improvement in exposure accuracy without specifiying that the camera/meter design was for this type of film or that type of film.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?