• Welcome to Photrio!
    Registration is fast and free. Join today to unlock search, see fewer ads, and access all forum features.
    Click here to sign up

In The American West

I was with 24 members of the Dallas Camera Club on a docent led visit May 20. I will go back on my own, of course, and possibly with the North Texas Film Photography group in June. It's interesting to be in a docent led group with other photographers and watching their various reactions. The docent, while not a photographer, was well prepared and very informative.

Yes, there are only 40 prints, but it would be difficult to mount all 124 due to space. Plus, in my opinion, any exhibit of more than 40 prints tends to give the viewer some fatigue after a certain point. I remember a Brett Weston show years ago with 132 prints! I love Brett's work, but I couldn't look at that many prints at one time!

Laura Wilson is giving a talk about the work at the Amon Carter on June 12.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Looking at Irving Penn's "Ethnographic Portraits 1967-71" in his Met Museum book "Centennial," I immediately thought of Avedon's western portraits and wonder if those pictures were a response to Penn's. In a way I found them quite similar. After all, Penn was Avedon's major competitor, both commercially and aesthetically. And it was no secret that Avedon was generally jealous of Penn.
 

Sometimes the windows are really clear.
East coast somewheres:

Not sure which mountainrange, maybe the Rockies or Sierra Nevadas or Cascades??

Then Shiprock NM
 

Attachments

  • C0015T01.jpg
    495.4 KB · Views: 129
  • C0016T01.jpg
    417 KB · Views: 117
Last edited:
And it was no secret that Avedon was generally jealous of Penn.
Do you have a source for that? Avedon and Penn were rivals, not enemies. Avedon had a set of Penn's cigarette butt photos in his personal collection.

According to Laura Wilson, this was not Avedon's initiative. The Amon Carter Museum approached him about doing the project. Also, if Avedon had been inspired by Penn's work for In The American West, it would have more likely been the Small Trades portraits.
 
Alan - yeah, Shiprock is evident in the second photo. The first aerial shot bears no resemblance whatsoever to either the Sierra or the Cascades. Possibly somewhere over E. New Mexico at the southern end of the Rockies.
 
Last edited:
Richard Avedon, by Irving Penn

 
Alan - I double checked on Google Earth. That aerial shot does indeed look like the Mt Taylor area southwest of Albuquerque in New Mexico. It's actually in south central NM. Mt Taylor is an extinct volcano over 11,000 ft high, so winter snow would be typical. The long straight lava flow to its south is a Natl Monument.
 
Last edited:

I traveled through Texas, including your wonderful city as a German tourist and never felt unsafe. Also lived in Detroit for 30 years and never felt safe.
 
Over many years Texas has mostly felt like a very safe place to do photography, when doing it inside a studio, or with a crew.
 
Last edited:
(Texas Old West Re-enactors all over the place)
 

Suggest you start with "Avedon: Something Personal," by Norma Stevens and Steven Aronson (2017)_ Although Avedon and Penn were friendly, it was well known that Avedon was afraid he would be remembered only as a fashion photographer, while Penn would be considered a great artist.
 
True. I reread the chapter about Penn and Avedon and there was certainly some resentment on Avedon's part about Penn being accepted by the art world (especially Szarkowsky at the Met). But there is little mention of jealousy, except a quote that Avedon was quite jealous of Penn's marriage to Lisa Fonseca. He certainly respected Penn's work but does not come across as jealous in the book.
 
Did you read the chapter quoting Avedon's psychiatrist, Robert Millman? I think he talked about that as well. And yes, he greatly respected Penn's work, which may have been part of the problem.
 
Did you read the chapter quoting Avedon's psychiatrist, Robert Millman? I think he talked about that as well. And yes, he greatly respected Penn's work, which may have been part of the problem.

I re-read that one, too. The only mention is of a dream suggesting he was afraid of Penn.
Whatever happened to doctor-patient priviledge?

Dr. Millman states early on he does not abide by what he considers ”old standards” as doctor-patient confidentiality. He says he enjoys talking about his often rich and famous patients.
 

Szarkowski (note the spelling) was at MoMA.
 
I consider Szarkowski the Moses of photography. He delivered the commandments and spoke with god-like authority from on high.

Actual photo of Szarkowski giving a lecture on Atget:

 
I consider Szarkowski the Moses of photography. He delivered the commandments and spoke with god-like authority from on high.

I wholeheartedly agree. For me, some of his writings transcend their ostensible subject and are literary works of art in their own right.