• Welcome to Photrio!
    Registration is fast and free. Join today to unlock search, see fewer ads, and access all forum features.
    Click here to sign up

In a Fix – The two times fixer rule

Denis K

Member
Allowing Ads
Joined
Jun 24, 2009
Messages
237
Format
35mm
I’ve heard the rule ‘always fix your film for twice as long as it takes to clear’ quoted more often than I can recall, but have always wondered who it was first attributed to. Although I suspect this is not the first time it was quoted, I can at least trace it back to the year 1917. I was reading through an issue of Photo-Era magazine and came across the following reference which gives a good explanation of the rule and why it is so. I’ll let it speak for itself. Can someone come up with an earlier reference?

From: Photo-Era Magazine
Volume: XXXIX No: 2
Date: August 1917

Article: Stains on Negatives and Prints (Their Cause and Their Cure)
Author: Not Attributed


(b) Incomplete Fixing. This can occur even with a new bath if the print or film is taken from the bath too soon. While the plate is fixing, the silver halide in the emulsion changes first to colorless silver thiosulphate, which is comparatively insoluble. At this point the milkiness of the plate or film disappears. By leaving the plate in the bath this soluble and colorless compound is changed to a more soluble double thiosulphate of silver, which can be easily washed out. When the film is removed from the fixing-bath immediately after the milkiness has disappeared – the first stage of fixing – no amount of washing, later, will remove the insoluble silver salt, and this will in time be changed to yellow silver sulphide stain. The only safe rule is the leave all prints and negatives in the fixing-bath for double the time required to reach the end of the first stage, which is marked by the disappearance of the milkiness.

(c) If prints or negatives have not been completely covered while in the fixing-bath, they may appear completely fixed; but in spots they may have fixed only as far as the first stage, with the result that on exposure to the air yellow stains will appear.
 
I'm travelling at the moment, so, I can't check my library, but I can think of two possible pieces of literature where one could find an earlier statement.

1. The Photographic Research Papers of Ferdinand Hurter & Vero C. Driffield
2. The First Edition of the Ilford Manual of Photography

Both references are prior to 1900.
 
I'd rather trust my 1890 "Manual of Photography" these books you reference are just too new

Not sure but I think the "Manual of Photography" (Ilford) series pre-dates similar Agfa publications, it certainly pre-dates anything from the last in first out Kodak (well they were the first to stop making B&W papers).

But as I'm sure Ralph knows they aren't actually that far out of date even now, some even recommend Rodinal

Ian