How to remove coating from front lens element?

dslater

Member
Joined
Dec 6, 2005
Messages
740
Location
Hollis, NH
Format
35mm

Here's a direct link to the page:

http://www.naturfotograf.com/UV_IR_rev05.html#top_page

Martin,
Bjørn uses frames on his site. If you have the Firefox browser, you can right click on his page and choose "This Frame" ==> "View Frame Info" to get the frame's address.

Dan
 

dslater

Member
Joined
Dec 6, 2005
Messages
740
Location
Hollis, NH
Format
35mm
By the same logic, table salt (NaCl) would be a metal, since sodium (Na) is a metal.....ouch!

And its MgF2, by the way, not MgF.

Well if it's (NaCl) not a metallic salt, then what is it?
 

acroell

Member
Joined
Jun 7, 2004
Messages
101
Location
Huntsville, AL, USA
Format
Multi Format
Well if it's (NaCl) not a metallic salt, then what is it?

Its a metal salt, not a metallic salt. I may be out on a limb here languagewise since I am not a native speaker and I infer it from German, but "metallic" is an adjective and when used with a noun would ascribe the properties of a metal to the object named by the noun; properties like electric conductivity, heat conductivity, reflectivity etc. Table salt certainly has no metallic properties.
A salt is ionic.
The sentence starting this was
"Later photographic lens coatings are very thin metallic deposits which are deposited onto the lens by sublimation methods (Putting the lens in a chamber with a blob of alloy and zapping it with a huge current so is vapourises and re-condenses on the lens, for example...)."

Steven clearly meant metals here because he talks about an alloy, not a compound. Metallic coatings are sometimes used but not as AR coatings; mirror coatings are the obvious use. Dan pointed that out by mentioning magnesium fluoride as the tradiitional AR coating material.
 

steven_e007

Member
Joined
Mar 13, 2007
Messages
826
Location
Shropshire,
Format
Multi Format


Actually, Steven meant no such thing.
Steven was merely being careless, because, being new to the forum, Steven wasn't quite prepared for how intricately every post is picked apart for errors such as these!

Steven has since wised up

Most modern techniques involve evapourating the metal *halide* in a vacuum. Not the metal. And yes I did confuse the method with coating a mirror as I had been involved with a problem involving damaged front silvered mirrors that week...

...but, point was, there are several types of lens coating. Magnesium flouride is usually used for all modern camera lenses. Years ago manufacturers, especially in the US (MgF2 was an exclusively German technology in WW2, wasn't it?) used other techniques, including chemical glass etching and soft coatings.

Soft coatings are still used today for spectacles and consist of dunking the lenses in coloured goos and cooking them onto the surface. Some WW2 vintage Kodak lenses were coated in this way.

Soft coatings are going to be faily easy to remove, I suspect.
Hard coatings are going to be extremely difficult.
Etched glass is probably impossible, since it isn't really a coating...

So, knowing what type of coating you have would seem to be essential before attempting any of the suggested techniques for removal, I think.

Steve
 

dslater

Member
Joined
Dec 6, 2005
Messages
740
Location
Hollis, NH
Format
35mm

I am a native speaker and I believe you're mistaken here. I have read many things being referred to a metallic salts. While it is true metallic is an adjective, it does not metallic as in something with properties like electric conductivity, heat conductivity, reflectivity etc. - it refers to the periodic table of the elements where every element is either a metal, a non-metal, a halogen, or an inert element.

here's a link to the table:

http://images.google.com/imgres?img...Fp2PMYl1MvuRjQNw&sa=X&oi=images&ct=image&cd=1

Dan
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…