Ralph is spot on here.the 180 is asupersharp lens and often overlooked.
I think you need to evaluate your opinion. In light of the pandemic disease sweeping the globe. Facts are proving to be the solution. These curves are facts. If you wish to ignore them ,so be it.That is the standard internet cliche. Can that really be demonstrated in online posted pictures or optical prints? Most of this xxx is "sharper" than yyy is a bunch of online nonsense.
I am not ignoring the curves. In this case , the MTF curves do show that the 100mm lens performs better than the 80. But my original statement is still correct: Most of this xxx is "sharper" than yyy is a bunch of online nonsense. The internet is full of this kind of drivel that does not contribute to real photography, just bragging rights or brick wall photos.These curves are facts. If you wish to ignore them ,so be it.
I am not ignoring the curves. In this case , the MTF curves do show that the 100mm lens performs better than the 80. But my original statement is still correct: Most of this xxx is "sharper" than yyy is a bunch of online nonsense. The internet is full of this kind of drivel that does not contribute to real photography, just bragging rights or brick wall photos.
I own both lenses and it is definitely not nonsense. The 100mm is a noticeably better performer, especially outside the center of the frame, and has much lower distortion. The 80mm also suffers from horrendous coma at wide apertures. Does all of this make the 80mm a bad lens? No, it is still quite capable of making stunning photographs. But the 100mm *is* technically a much higher performer, and no amount of scoffing will change that.
Good... now I am thinking about changing my kit. I like the 50mm, I have the CF FLE... so, instead of getting the 80mm and 150mm, maybe I should go for the 100mm and 180mm. And, if I need a really long lens, I can go straight to the 350mm, instead of the 250mm.
+ 1I am not ignoring the curves. In this case , the MTF curves do show that the 100mm lens performs better than the 80. But my original statement is still correct: Most of this xxx is "sharper" than yyy is a bunch of online nonsense. The internet is full of this kind of drivel that does not contribute to real photography, just bragging rights or brick wall photos.
Not to mention that I can hand hold the 100 with a great deal of confidence, but not the awkward 180. ...
If I could have only one out of 150, 180, and 250, I would choose the 180
50, 100, 180 is a good combo. (FWIW, at some point I replaced the 50 by 60 in "daily use" mainly for its lower size & weight)Good... now I am thinking about changing my kit. I like the 50mm, I have the CF FLE... so, instead of getting the 80mm and 150mm, maybe I should go for the 100mm and 180mm. And, if I need a really long lens, I can go straight to the 350mm, instead of the 250mm.
EDIT: or forget about the 100 and go straight to the 120 - the most useful lens of all in my opinion.
Definitely. The decision becomes "which one to get first" and this is a completely different debate.I think it is valid to buy both. They excel in different applications.
BTW a much cheaper way to discover your perfect lens is an app similar to artist viewfinder. I have all relevant Hasselblad lenses added to it so you can quickly see the difference in FOV between them.
I have a borrowed 80mm and for my urban shots, it was a little too long, but for my landscape shots it was perfect. While I hemmed and hawed over getting a 60 (which was cheaper then), the prices went up quite a bit. The 50mm was budget-priced comparatively like a year ago. Now they're all crazy town. As I'm getting older I started to realize that I need to buy the lenses that I need and put that kit to bed. My 4x5 kit is complete, along with my 35mm. I own the 150mm and thinking I'll get the 80mm and the 250mm and call it good. I was thinking, "I'll settle for a C lens" but that doesn't work anymore since the price differential has closed. I'm not sure why this is happening shouldn't everyone be using their cell phones and leaving this gear alone?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?