• Welcome to Photrio!
    Registration is fast and free. Join today to unlock search, see fewer ads, and access all forum features.
    Click here to sign up

Good Portrait Photography

Cemetery Chapel

H
Cemetery Chapel

  • 2
  • 0
  • 30
2 bath test

A
2 bath test

  • 3
  • 0
  • 54

Recent Classifieds

Forum statistics

Threads
202,770
Messages
2,845,335
Members
101,514
Latest member
Luc Tourwé
Recent bookmarks
0
I've been a portrait photographer for nearly sixty years and the only one of these people I have ever heard of is Steve McCurry and I would say he's a photojournalist not primarily a portrait photographer.
 
The subject of THIS post is misleading: TRAVEL portraits, i.e. otherwise could be called documentary portraits. I know 7 or so.
 
Blimey. Most of them look like they've been taken by the same person. Maybe they're the digital ones! And as others said, it some travel thing. Loads more famous portrait photographers out there I think.
 
That post is just link bait, I wouldn't get too concerned about who's on the list. They just needed to fill the page with names and photos. If they are really doing their homework they probably based the list on names people search for most often.
 
If I remember correctly, McCurry's famous photo was a virtual grab shot. Wasn't it?
A great photo... Absolutely. Documentary... Yes.
A portrait? Only in the sense that it portrays the likeness of a person at a specific moment in time.
It's more of a candid, IMHO. A very, very good candid. :smile:
 
You would really have to be a crap photographer to shoot a picture of such a beautiful young woman with such incredible eyes and it not be good.
 
You've explained it to me. I went to the site and thought 'well if portrait is finding someone who looks interesting and then just pointing a camera at them in whatever light is there.'
 
You would really have to be a crap photographer to shoot a picture of such a beautiful young woman with such incredible eyes and it not be good.

Congratualtions on minimizing one of the most influential photos in the past forty years.

The hard part wasn't taking the photograph, it was seeing the girl in the refuge camp in the first place, taking the moment to make the connection with her, so she showed her eyes, composing the image to remove the bustling background, and getting the light & timing perfect. Sure, it would take a crap photographer to mess up her portrait, but it took a good photographer to see her in the first place.

Steve McCurry calls himself a photojournalist, but he has done a great deal of environmental portraits in his time. Personally, I'd say those are his best photos.
http://stevemccurry.com/galleries

Going back to the original subject, I recognize the photos of one or two of the photographers. I'll agree, they all fall into what I consider travel photography, not classic portraiture, and I doubt any but Steve McCurry are truely famous. Personally, my list would have included people shooting the covers of major publications that hundreds of thousands or millions of people read, or adverts that are plastered in front of billions of eyes. Almost no non-photographers recognizes a famous photographer's name, but many will recall a few famous images they've seen. Annie Leibovitz, Martin Schoeller, Greg Heisler, Dan Winters, Joey L. I'd have loved to see a list of similar photographers shooting and being published in the east; India and China in particular, since those images will fall on a lot of eyes.

As was said, the link was pure click-bait, and so the list was really "these are my favour photographers".
 
Congratualtions on minimizing one of the most influential photos in the past forty years.

The hard part wasn't taking the photograph, it was seeing the girl in the refuge camp in the first place, taking the moment to make the connection with her, so she showed her eyes, composing the image to remove the bustling background, and getting the light & timing perfect. Sure, it would take a crap photographer to mess up her portrait, but it took a good photographer to see her in the first place.

Steve McCurry calls himself a photojournalist, but he has done a great deal of environmental portraits in his time. Personally, I'd say those are his best photos.
http://stevemccurry.com/galleries

Going back to the original subject, I recognize the photos of one or two of the photographers. I'll agree, they all fall into what I consider travel photography, not classic portraiture, and I doubt any but Steve McCurry are truely famous. Personally, my list would have included people shooting the covers of major publications that hundreds of thousands or millions of people read, or adverts that are plastered in front of billions of eyes. Almost no non-photographers recognizes a famous photographer's name, but many will recall a few famous images they've seen. Annie Leibovitz, Martin Schoeller, Greg Heisler, Dan Winters, Joey L. I'd have loved to see a list of similar photographers shooting and being published in the east; India and China in particular, since those images will fall on a lot of eyes.

As was said, the link was pure click-bait, and so the list was really "these are my favour photographers".

It is a beautiful iconic picture, but what you describe as the method that McCurry used is only the way any half competent shooter who wasn't a happy snapper would approach the subject, and the difficulty of the photographer in obtaining an image has little bearing on the actual picture when viewed by the public who can only judge what's in front of them.
How many members of this forum could have taken this shot given the same circumstances ? quite a few I bet.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
It is a beautiful iconic picture, but what you describe as the method that McCurry used is only the way any half competent shooter who wasn't a happy snapper would approach the subject, and the difficulty of the photographer in obtaining an image has little bearing on the actual picture when viewed by the public who can only judge what's in front of them.
How many members of this forum could have taken this shot given the same circumstances ? quite a few I bet.
Come on...
 
How many members of this forum could have taken this shot given the same circumstances ? quite a few I bet.

But the fact is they didn't and he did. It is far easier to criticise than create.
 
But the fact is they didn't and he did. It is far easier to criticise than create.
I'm not criticising McCurry Clive, all I'm saying is it would have to be a really crap photographer to take a bad picture of a girl with such incredible eyes.
 
<Rant>
Dont like them and don't like the trend of posting such images over and over from travelling to any destination.

These photos remind me of what I read in the NG portrait book.
Roughly paraphrased quote:
What resulted was that National Geographic photographers went to exotic, unexplored lands and brought back photos of the people from there.

Almost everyone seems to be a poor person photographed, and shoving wide-angle/tele In-Your-Face and taking a photo seems to be the in-thing.
Why does a portrait have to be only the face or face+shoulders?
Caricature is better.

</Rant>

+1 to what Mike C & Adolorenzo said!
 
Cheesy, overprocessed pictures of third world faces, full blown at entire frame. Not interested, sorry. Been here, seen what...

Good Portrait Photography is with Yousuf Karsh as very well staged with perfect light images and with Jane Bown's quick, but perfect style.
Those at the link aren't even close.
 
Portraits aren't just about showing someone's exterior face that they shown to the World, but more about trying to reveal their soul .
 
Wow!!!

Jane Bown's camera: OM-1 + 85mm f/2.0 what a great combo.
 
If that's true, I would say almost all portraiture probably fails.
Most of them do fail Michael, but it should be what a good portraitist should be trying to achieve.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Photrio.com contains affiliate links to products. We may receive a commission for purchases made through these links.
To read our full affiliate disclosure statement please click Here.

PHOTRIO PARTNERS EQUALLY FUNDING OUR COMMUNITY:



Ilford ADOX Freestyle Photographic Stearman Press Weldon Color Lab Blue Moon Camera & Machine
Top Bottom