Good LCD Monitor?

sanking · Apr 5, 2007

I need a new monitor, and am interested in an LCD in the 22" - 25" range.

Any first hand wisdom on the best buys for price and performance in this category much appreciated.

Sandy King

livemoa · Apr 5, 2007

Hi Sandy, I started a thread a while back on the same subject, have a look here for some comments http://www.hybridphoto.com/forums/showthread.php?t=198

Still haven't got round to replacing mine, a friend has coaxed some more life out of my existing monitor.

Pinholemaster · Apr 5, 2007

Apple just lowered the price of the fabulous 23" monitor. $899

Sean · Apr 5, 2007

I've had a 20inch Apple Cinema display for about a year now and it is amazing, would love the 23 and if I won lotto would get the 24inch iMac (the display on the new 24inch iMac is the best looking display I have ever seen)

tim rudman · Apr 6, 2007

Sean said:
I've had a 20inch Apple Cinema display for about a year now and it is amazing, would love the 23 and if I won lotto would get the 24inch iMac (the display on the new 24inch iMac is the best looking display I have ever seen)

I suppose these can only be used with Macs??
What about PCs? I'm in the same position as Sandy and plan to replace this year.
Tim

clay · Apr 6, 2007

They will work on any computer with a DVI connector, which is now pretty common in Macs and PCs. I bought some of these for PCs at my office. They are very nice, and oh-so-sleek.

tim rudman said:
I suppose these can only be used with Macs??
What about PCs? I'm in the same position as Sandy and plan to replace this year.
Tim

tim rudman · Apr 6, 2007

clay said:
They will work on any computer with a DVI connector, which is now pretty common in Macs and PCs. I bought some of these for PCs at my office. They are very nice, and oh-so-sleek.

Thanks Clay

Ted Harris · Apr 7, 2007

At the current price the Apple 23" Cinema Display is the hands down winner. Take a look at Eizo's too but I don't think they have anything in that price range for that size.

I have a 23" Cinema Display that is now pushing 3 and also 3 Eizo's ... all are steller performers.

sanking · Apr 7, 2007

I gather from the responses so far that no one considers that any of the consumner type LCD monitors in the 22" - 24" range deserve any consideration? By that I mean the type of LCD monitors on would find at CompUSA or on ebay in the $350 - $600 range.

Sandy King

clay · Apr 7, 2007

We bought two of these monitors for our Sun Workstations. They have this nifty rotating feature so you can see a display in portrait mode my rotating the monitor. They seem to be pretty nice.

http://review.zdnet.com/HP_LP2465/4505-3174_16-31919307.html?tag=pdtl-img

sanking said:
I gather from the responses so far that no one considers that any of the consumner type LCD monitors in the 22" - 24" range deserve any consideration? By that I mean the type of LCD monitors on would find at CompUSA or on ebay in the $350 - $600 range.

Sandy King

Kerik · Apr 8, 2007

Sandy,

I have had one of these for about a year and a half and have been happy with it. It took some getting used to at first coming from a CRT. The built in adjustments are kind of limited, but the driver for my video card gives all the adjustments I want and more.

danschmidt · Apr 8, 2007

Sandy,

I think you will be quite satisfied with the more mid-range monitors.

I usually use www.newegg.com for comparison purposes and frequently buy from them too.

We buy many monitors at my work and often default to Acer brand as good price perfomance compromise.

You also might think about using two monitors, for me it is a very productive way to work.

You can get two 19" monitors for $400. One monitor can have say an image filling the whole screen while all the toolbars and such can be on the other.

-dan

L Gebhardt · Apr 8, 2007

I have a 23" Cinema display and it is great. I also have a Dell 30" which is just as good. I wouldn't hesitate to try the 24" Dell. The Dells don't have the same feel as the Cinema Displays but they are much cheaper with very similar image quality.

Last I looked at the cheap 24" displays at CompUSA I found them lacking, but there may be some good ones out there.

MAGNAchrom · Apr 9, 2007

I have two of these and they are very good:

Dead Link Removed

Cheers

Kino · Apr 9, 2007

We use the 23 inch Apple Cinema Displays at work for 2K motion picture restoration on HP xw 8000 dual processor Xeon workstations (PCs) and love them; they have been real workhorses! I only wish we had 2 per workstation OR we had the 30 inch screens!

As long as you have a graphics card with enough horsepower, you are fine. We use ATI Fire Graphics cards at work, but I am partial to the Quattro Pro Nvidia Series for serious graphics work -- besides, the higher-end software packages for Digital Intermediate and Color correction in the motion picture business use the gellato CPU code from Nvidia.

sanking · Apr 11, 2007

Well, I solved the monitor issue by purchasing a new 24" iMac. It was kind of like buying a big monitor and getting the computer for free.

Sandy

sanking · Apr 20, 2007

Just an update on this.

The new 24" iMac is here and working great. The screen is really a delight to work with.

However, I still wound up getting a new LCD monitor for the old G4, which I need to run one of my scanners. I got a 22" Samsung SyncMaster 225 BW for $270, delivered. I have the new iMac and the old G4 in the same room and can pretty much visually compare both monitors. I don't believe there is any doubt but that the 24" monitor on the iMac is better, but the Samsung is surprisingly good, much better than some of the other 22" monitors I looked at locally.

But the big iMac is quite something.

Sandy

SusanV · Apr 21, 2007

Sandy, thanks for the update on this. I've been looking at LCD's, and the Samsungs seem to be good bang for the buck. Good to hear your first hand opinion on them.

Yeah I'll bet that 24" iMac is fantastic. Have fun.

susan

timeUnit · Aug 8, 2007

I'd like to add that as a user of Apple 23 inch Cinema Displays in color critical applications, I find the monitor to be a joke. Garbage. We have 20 + Apple CD 23's in our office, regularly calibrated and most of them suck. Sure, they look nice, but that's it. The real color-critical guys and gals have replaced the Apples with Eizo ColorEdge 21 inch, and are happy with them. My cheap 20 inch Philips LCD at home is much more accurate than my Apple CD.

The inaccuracy lies in that different parts of the screen have different hues. I.e. poor uniformity.

This monitor is a few years old now, so maybe the new CD's are better. But I would not recommend them for other than good looks.

bdial · May 18, 2009

Any new recomendations now that there are 23 inch monitors in consumer oriented stores?
Thanks

Carl1 · Dec 14, 2009

Sandy,

The video card and the monitor are a matched pair. If you want to improve the quality of the monitor start with the video card first. Id suggest a ATI HD5870 and use the 10bit display port adapter for your monitor. Then get the Eizo CG243W and again use the 10 bit display port input. This combination will allow you to see things you have never seen before on any of your images.

Keep it all profiled of course when your all set up and it will be like getting a new pair of glasses. I use this setup for softproofing my drum scanned film.

Carl

www.mondragonfineart.com

pschwart · Dec 17, 2009

What about a value alternative? Most of us are not going to spend > $2000 on a monitor.

Carl said:
Sandy,

The video card and the monitor are a matched pair. If you want to improve the quality of the monitor start with the video card first. Id suggest a ATI HD5870 and use the 10bit display port adapter for your monitor. Then get the Eizo CG243W and again use the 10 bit display port input. This combination will allow you to see things you have never seen before on any of your images.

Keep it all profiled of course when your all set up and it will be like getting a new pair of glasses. I use this setup for softproofing my drum scanned film.

Carl

www.mondragonfineart.com

donbga · Dec 18, 2009

pschwart said:
What about a value alternative? Most of us are not going to spend > $2000 on a monitor.

The NEC wide gamut monitors provide that value IMO. Coupled with their Spectraview calibration software, great results are virtually guaranteed.

SWphoto · Dec 18, 2009

Sandy,

Larry, the owner of OWC Computing (you know, the hard drive, memory place), had recently recommended an Acer 24" as being a great value for editing:

Totally excellent ACER 24" White LED Backlit Display w/Built-In USB2 Hub & Speakers for $295. This display is a brand new model and is exceptional! The clarity, non-blurring responsiveness, and color accuracy is that you'd find and expect of displays costing far more. We spent a lot of time testing a lot of displays before we made this our feature offering. You won't find a better deal on a better display. 1920x1080, DVI & VGA. 3 Year warranty.

It's on sale now for $285. I'd have been leery of an Acer, but Larry's not one to tout this stuff unless he really has checked it out. If I were in the market, I'd seriously consider it.

Rick

donbga · Dec 18, 2009

Rick said:
Sandy,

Larry, the owner of OWC Computing (you know, the hard drive, memory place), had recently recommended an Acer 24" as being a great value for editing:

Totally excellent ACER 24" White LED Backlit Display w/Built-In USB2 Hub & Speakers for $295. This display is a brand new model and is exceptional! The clarity, non-blurring responsiveness, and color accuracy is that you'd find and expect of displays costing far more. We spent a lot of time testing a lot of displays before we made this our feature offering. You won't find a better deal on a better display. 1920x1080, DVI & VGA. 3 Year warranty.

It's on sale now for $285. I'd have been leery of an Acer, but Larry's not one to tout this stuff unless he really has checked it out. If I were in the market, I'd seriously consider it.

Rick

Considering that this is a 2-year old thread your recommendations may have came a little too late.

Aside from that I don't think the ACER is a good value, for editing.

Is this a wide gamut monitor? I doubt it at this price.

Don Bryant

Good LCD Monitor?

Admin

Privacy & Transparency

Privacy & Transparency