Just to give a 'flip side of the coin' account of Acros here. I love the film too, and have found that it is very much a chameleon.
At box speed I get very good shadow detail and great separation all the way up to the brightest tones. So much so that I have no reason at all to shoot at 80, 64, or 50. I use replenished Xtol like this and love how it prints at Grade 2 filtration for the most part.
I also use it at EI 400 and develop in Xtol 1+1, agitating every two minutes when I develop. This gives me a tone curve that looks almost identical to the old Tri-X 320, and in 35mm has such fine grain and resolution that it has the same grain as the medium format Tri-X in a print.
So it's very flexible, and what I wanted to show with my examples was that you do not have to develop it like everybody else does. You can, with a test roll or two, learn how it's optimal for you in different lighting conditions. Print your negatives. Get a step wedge and make contact sheets. That will tell you a lot about how you're doing with your film development, and a lot about how your tones will be rendered.
- Thomas