I hesitated to respond because I've only used FP-100C in the "common" size and not in 4x5. If they are the same, then I had this happen once when the rollers got dirty... the black tab failed to come through. I was able to open the back of the camera, find and grab the black tab, and then pull it out. I did not try to put the tab into the rollers manually, but just got it out so that I could use the rest of the pack normally. It worked... I gave it a good pull and everything that normally comes out did, but the photo was not developed and the little packet of developing chemicals was unbroken. After I was done with that pack of film I washed the accumulated gunk off the rollers with warm soapy water and it never happened again. So... it IS possible!