Matt, I used to think this way until I bought this Rokinon. I shoot tethered to a computer, and use focus sampler in software. It shows me that sharp corners at different focus distance than the center. Besides, people in old APUG threads and on photo.net used to argue about field flatness of their macros in the past. Even in a recent convo here someone said that enlarger lenses have a flatter field than "most macros". So now I am losing my trust in the "macro" moniker.