Fixing film for less time than fiber-base paper...?? No way that seems right to me. The paper-fixing times seem alright, but do do a clip test for your film to establish a minimum fixing time for each film you use.
My recommendation: Find the time it takes the film to clear in fresh fixer (search here or elsewhere on how to do a film-clearing test if you don't know how) and triple the time to get your minimum time. Times will be different for different films. The clearing test will tell you if the manufacturer's recommendations are correct. Keep in mind that fixing film a bit longer than absolutely necessary does no harm and may ensure that you don't underfix.
Do a clearing test before each batch to test fixer exhaustion. When the clearing time hits double that in fresh fixer, discard the fixer.
Note, the above is for film only. For prints, throughput is your guide to fixer capacity. Do residual silver tests with ST-1 or selenium toner to test for adequate fixing of prints.
Best,
Doremus