• Welcome to Photrio!
    Registration is fast and free. Join today to unlock search, see fewer ads, and access all forum features.
    Click here to sign up

Extreme Contrast with MG Classic

Joined
Jan 21, 2003
Messages
15,715
Location
Switzerland
Format
Multi Format

Doremus,

My experience with Pyro staining developers is that sometimes with variable contrast papers I actually get less contrast due to the stain. Would your technique above possibly be more meant for use with Graded papers? I've used papers like Kentmere Bromide and Fotokemika Emaks with Pyrocat-MC and PMK negatives and saw a marked contrast increase using those developers, but noticed the opposite when printing the same negatives with papers like Ilford MGIV and MG Classic.
 
Joined
Jan 21, 2003
Messages
15,715
Location
Switzerland
Format
Multi Format

The color makes sense, thinking about how VC paper is constructed with its combination of emulsions and their light sensitivity.
The Pyrocat negatives tend to have a brown stain, not at all as green as with PMK.
 
Joined
Sep 10, 2002
Messages
3,675
Location
Eugene, Oregon
Format
4x5 Format
At the risk of hijacking the thread: Since we're debunking myths here, I think the old, "pyro stain produces less contrast on VC papers" myth should go too. Maybe there's a graduated contrast effect with no filter, but think about it a minute, a green stain under magenta light passes even less light than a neutral-colored negative would. If anything, there should be more contrast in the denser areas of the negative with the stain than without it. The effect is, since magenta light has no green component, to pass blue only, but even less of it.

Try this mental experiment: take a #2 contrast filter and make a print. Make the same print with a # 5 filter (it'll be contrastier). Then sandwich the #2 filter (representing pyro stain) together with a #5 filter and make a print. It's going to end up matching the print made with just the #5 filter but will take more exposure.

Strong magenta filtration with a pyro stain should result in the same, or even more, contrast as a negative without stain. The problem is, there is no easy way to design a test to show this. VC papers don't respond the same way as graded papers, stained negs don't have the same distribution of tones as non-stained, etc.

I used to believe that the stain had a contrast-reducing effect and went round and round about it with Nicholas Linden till he finally convinced me that there is no way to definitively show that this is true.

Best,

Doremus
 
Joined
Jan 21, 2003
Messages
15,715
Location
Switzerland
Format
Multi Format

I can only tell you what I noticed in my prints, which is why I asked.
 
OP
OP

silvergelatin

Member
Joined
Jul 19, 2015
Messages
112
Location
Japan
Format
35mm
Dokumol at 1+4 dilution?

This actually helped a bit. I've been waiting for my next shipment of Dokumol, and found an old unopened bottle today hidden away in the corner. I drained out 500ml from my Nova and added in straight concentrate. Got a good contrast boost from that. Not huge, but made a nice difference. I'll be ditching 1+6 going forward and mixing 1L into 1 gallon of working solution. Expensive this way, but worth it.

Has anyone tried doing a quick pre-dev dip in a tray of straight concentrate? Would it in theory give the shadows a head start, or affect all tones equally?
 

Doc W

Member
Allowing Ads
Joined
Nov 7, 2009
Messages
955
Location
Ottawa, Cana
Format
Large Format

If you already up to the highest grade you can get with that paper, I think you should just try another paper. Ilford Classic (and the older MGIV) does not let you get really high contrast (comparatively speaking) . Another paper would be the short route, and likely less frustrating.
 

David Allen

Member
Allowing Ads
Joined
Nov 6, 2008
Messages
991
Location
Berlin
Format
Med. Format RF
The description of Dokumol is more akin to a developer that produces great gradation. You might wish to seek out a paper developer with stronger contrast.

Dokumol at 1 + 6 is a very contrasty and hard working developer. With most fibre papers you will get the best results developing between 3.5 - 4.5 minutes.

If that does not give you enough contrast you can try progressively adding small amounts of Caustic Soda to the Dokumol. HOWEVER, you need to be extremely careful using Caustic Soda as it is corrosive.

Bests,

David.
www.dsallen.de
 
Joined
Jan 21, 2003
Messages
15,715
Location
Switzerland
Format
Multi Format

Yes, it looks as though this description I found on Freestyle's web site is not representative of what the developer actually does. I apologize if my misinformation caused confusion. Just for the record.
 

M Carter

Member
Allowing Ads
Joined
Jan 23, 2013
Messages
2,149
Location
Dallas, TX
Format
Medium Format
Man, I'd say give lith a try before permanently altering the neg. If you want to tone down the lith effect, do room temp and a pretty dilute mix. (Of course, the paper has to be lithable to go there...)