Rodinal - magic! I have many rolls of a lot expired in 1996, and when I develop it in Rodinal it sings, and is almost completely fog free! I use 1+200, 500ml per roll, 70*F, 30 minutes, agitate first 90 seconds continuously, then two inversions every 5 minutes.
I have also tried it with Pyrocat - no go. I got some kind of problem with it that caused spots. When I developed Plus-X and Tri-X in the same tank even, and the Tri-X came out perfect! I've also tried Edwal 12 and HC-110. HC-110 works best of the two, the Edwal 12 for some reason likes to add density along the edge of the film, and I'm completely dumbfounded why that is.
But in Rodinal the stuff rules! I've seen it developed in D23 with stunning results too.
- Thomas