I guess he considers any film that's unexposed as "New". After all, nobody has run it through a camera yet, so it can hardly be characterized as "Used".
Well, its still NEW, meaning never been used. Used film would have been open and maybe exposed. As long as seller states its expired, its buyer beware.
I agree, I guess a equate New and Fresh as the same... Anyway I would have bidded on the several of his film auctions.... But I guess he was to sensitive when I question it... Oh well.