I made some once, it waorked fine, but the life span of a bouble potasium collodion is only a couple of weeks from what I have heard. Make a small batch and try it to see what you think. From an economy stand point, a cadmium collodion will last quit a few months, so if you do'nt use it for a few weeks you wo'nt be out anything, but then again it is a cadmium collodion. I make Estebrooks collodion for positives, it has two cadmiums init, I like it better than old relyable or workhorse, sill here to talk about it. If you use cadmium, just wash your hands after handling it.