• Welcome to Photrio!
    Registration is fast and free. Join today to unlock search, see fewer ads, and access all forum features.
    Click here to sign up

Does a location being "touristy" diminish the value of photographing it?

 

you obviously haven't seen any of the photographs i am refering to.

how about responding to eddie's question?
 
you obviously haven't seen any of the photographs i am refering to.

Please make your point by linking some of Calahan's "touristy" photos. I must have overlooked them. Dead Link Removed

What I see in Callahan is a brilliant professional illustrative/photojournalist ..no "touristy" locations but plenty of serendipity.
 
I answered with regard to the question in thread title. A "touristy" location infers the unavoidability of tourists.

OK... I'm a native San Francisco (transplanted). Somehow never photographed tourists. Was easy to avoid them.

In New Mexico the Pueblos with exception of Taos ban (with fines) photography by outsiders. In Taos they demand money (except for a few specified subjects).

From that I infer that positive value of tourist photos might be dubious.
 
Why don't you answer John's question?

eddie getting him to explain his comment seems to be a waste of electrons
i guess even with prodding IDK maybe he thinks if he doesn't respond
you won't remember he said it
back on the ignore list he goes !
( i suggest you do the same since he is trolling you )
 


A timeless landscape is one in which there are no clues of when the photograph was taken, such as cars, billboards, signs, people [clothes provide clues]. I prefer to let nature tell the story.
 
A timeless landscape is one in which there are no clues of when the photograph was taken, such as cars, billboards, signs, people [clothes provide clues]. I prefer to let nature tell the story.
There are contrails over the Amazon and Japanese outboards on the boats. The natives wear Nike. The South Pole might be the place you're looking for?
 
There are contrails over the Amazon and Japanese outboards on the boats. The natives wear Nike. The South Pole might be the place you're looking for?
You have to wait until signs dating the image are out of view.
 
There are contrails over the Amazon and Japanese outboards on the boats. The natives wear Nike. The South Pole might be the place you're looking for?

If ye seeks, ye can find. No need to got to Antarctica just for that; there are much better reasons.
 
I don't like posters.

People who post? That would include yourself.
I never said, referred to, or in anyway talk about taking poster like photographs. Do you ever read what individual post or do you just spew out posts based on what you had for breakfast? Do not waste my time. You are not worth it.
 
As you understand very well, my humour is reserved for people who believe landscape photographs denuded of any sign of human existence are more picturesque. The idea is at best old fashioned, and almost always derivative and clichéd. Touristy places are by definition full of tourists. To present them as otherwise is to misrepresent what such places have become.
 

Nature is not cliché and always in style for humans and animals.
 
I have to admit that my artist-in-residence (AIR) in Zion National Park for all of last April was a unique situation to be in. A very busy 'touristy' spot...presently in the top five national parks for visitors/year...and during Spring Break. A small Park with most visitors concentrated in a narrow long Zion Canyon, with some spread along the road east in the Checkerboard Mesa area.

Making visitor contacts was part of the AIR job description...20 hours/week requested...so several times with my 100 yr old 5x7 on the tripod over my shoulder I'd hike on busy trails and randomly set the camera up and let tourists look through it...sometimes I would even take a photo. Several hundred kids and adults from around the world looked thru my cameras...kinda neat. I screwed up several times with that many people around, but I usually realized it at the time and could re-shoot. Engaging the tourists while photographing was a rewarding experience.

However I just developed the last of the Zion film (some rolls of 120 and 12 5x7 sheets). I must admit, out of the all the negs, I don't remember any with people purposefully in them. Undoubtably there will be someone somewhere in my images that might be seen with a glass...and the shuttles that go up and down Zion Canyon ended up in a couple of photos. There's a dead Big Horn Sheep in a couple the 5x7s. I am most interested in the light reflecting off the landscape and being in beautiful and interesting places. But I also have a decade+ series of 8x10 platinum prints of my boys growing up in our local redwoods -- my three young tourists, with me as the tour guide.

Silver gelatin contact print, 5x7
Valley Tour, Yosemite Valley, ca 1993
and
Single-Transfer Carbon Print, 8x10
Three Boys, Three Snags, New Years Day 2008
Prairie Creek Redwoods State Park, CA
 

Attachments

  • ValleyTour.jpg
    124.4 KB · Views: 128
  • Three Boys Three Snags1.jpg
    887.3 KB · Views: 151
Last edited: