Do old, proven technologies attract certain mindsets?

Joined
Mar 21, 2005
Messages
984
Location
Athens
Format
Medium Format
I'm trying to remember that movie, in which there was a gag about a girl trying to dial a number on a phone with a rotary panel and not getting to figure out how it works (there was some kind of emergency). She just pushed the numbers with her long, painted fingernails and nothing happened...
 
Joined
Mar 21, 2005
Messages
984
Location
Athens
Format
Medium Format

We used to be somewhat "luddite" in our life philosophy... no TV, no cellular phones, listening to LPs (and CDs) on our stereo system... we resisted for a while... but slowly (and steadily) the advantages that modern technology has to offer got into our life, to make it more effective (theoretically).

Now we both own smartphones, gps devices, technical nanotechnology clothing, we watch blu-rays on an all-digital home-cinema, use tablets and PCs for a multitude of everyday tasks and keep updating our life's "automation" step-by-step... for example, our next project is a smart heater thermostat that can be controlled through the wi-fi connection using a smartphone from a remote point (even when you're away from home).

The upside: we can communicate when out of home (quite practical some times), we don't have to carry so many things when going out (the smartphone acts as filofax, walkman, phonebook, alarm clock, gps navigator etc etc) and sometimes spare money (renting a movie is much cheaper than the trip to the multiplex + 2 tickets, for example), we are safer and feel more comfortable when we go cycling on a mountain, etc.

The downside: those infernal machines make life very complicated sometimes, as they need constant maintenance (updates etc), get obsolete very quickly and break down often. Finally, we end up having paid more that we have saved (probably) to get them, maintain them and replace them when the time has come...

On the other hand, we still don't watch TV (disgusting !!!), we cook from scratch and listen to LPs (sometimes).

I could write a very long essay describing different cases of fails of modern technology, as well as the old one... and on the other hand the cases when it saved us from difficult situations... but I guess that almost every one has some similar stories to tell nowadays...

I have to say though, that the old stuff is much more fun to use...
 

Roger Cole

Member
Joined
Jan 20, 2011
Messages
6,069
Location
Atlanta GA
Format
Multi Format
I have a mix. I have vinyl, and CDs, and digital files, and listen to each at different times on different devices. Love my iPhone. I have a digital 3D 1080p projector with 5.1 surround sound home theater and love it. I don't hate everything new, I just like a lot of things old.
 

Truzi

Member
Joined
Mar 18, 2012
Messages
2,660
Format
Multi Format
When traveling to Hocking Hills, Ohio, we often stop at Dead Link Removed on the way (despite being lactose intolerant).

We were talking to the owner one day, and he explained their fail-safe system. First, when employing a new teenager, they teach them to COUNT CHANGE!

They also have some vintage mechanical NCR cash registers. They maintain them very well, and have the electronic add-ons. However, they keep the cranks just in case of a power failure. Credit/debit transactions use a credit-card machine connected to the internet, but as a fail-safe, they keep a modem active (and ultimately, the old swipe-machine).
 

blockend

Member
Joined
Aug 16, 2010
Messages
5,049
Location
northern eng
Format
35mm
This summer I had to confront the awful truth that my iPhone shots were better than any photography I'd done for decades. This was for two reasons. The first was technical, the small sensor gives a massive depth of field which, along with the high contrast daylight, suited the subject. The second and most important reason was the charged emotional nature of the topic would have excluded anything that resembled a real camera, or at least changed it in undesirable ways.

As someone with an attraction to process which analogue systems provide, whether it be putting a stylus on a vinyl record, or mixing developer, the idea than all that ritual can be replaced and something artistically superior emerge at the other end, is something I still have to get my head around.

I remember an interview with Barry "Dame Edna" Humphreys the comedian, where he admitted his extensive antique book collection was simply a way of pretending he had ballast, instead of being a figment of his own imagination who belonged nowhere and might float away entirely. I think analogue systems with their hardware index dials and rituals represent a similar kind of certainty, and not one we can easily throw off. Outcomes alone aren't always enough.
 

gleaf

Member
Joined
Dec 9, 2012
Messages
273
Location
Kentucky
Format
Large Format
Proven technology means 'mature' to me. The problems are known and the wisdom is being passed down to new practitioners. There are work around methods known to be problems, for the over sensitive or under sensitive reactions. The down side is market share dropping and financial realities set in. Dwindling availability of spares and repair parts as the old fabrication processes are retired. For example 40 years ago they threw away 10,000 electron tube tweeking in the production run. Now there is no 10,000 tube run quantity as full production. What you get is much less stable in its low quantity custom production run. There is a 20 year out spot of old 60's technology that rapidly closes by 40 - 50 years. Newer digital things are often out of production in under three years. It is hard to finish a design before the parts you panned to use are no longer recommended for new production these days in electronics.
Happy keeper of the flame life style.
 

analoguey

Member
Joined
Jul 24, 2013
Messages
1,103
Location
Bangalore, I
Format
Multi Format

+1

Also, to the OP -whether proven or 'bleeding-edge' tech, both require a 'certain mindset' to buy.
Age and experiences colour it, of course.
 

blockend

Member
Joined
Aug 16, 2010
Messages
5,049
Location
northern eng
Format
35mm
Progress as an idea, is largely mythical. Ideologues cite examples like anaesthetic or universal suffrage, both of which I fully commend, but what have we lost along the way? To buy into progress, especially the instantly outmoded world of digital photography, requires an almost religious commitment to the superiority of this new thing over that old thing.

To take photography seriously, at some point you're going to have to invest in the ability of the equipment to enable the vision, something believers in progress rarely do. They want the next but one thing, and they want it yesterday. That is not good for anyone's head.
 
OP
OP

David Lyga

Member
Joined
Nov 25, 2007
Messages
3,445
Location
Philadelphia
Format
35mm
To take photography seriously, at some point you're going to have to invest in the ability of the equipment to enable the vision, something believers in progress rarely do.

Sagaciously said, blockend. I knew there were logical 'reasons' for the love of analog.

Immediately new and immediatly 'old', digital provides us with a superior theory of image caputure that just might not synergize with the staying power of the actual hardware. And ... I knew that there was a reason that all those 'superior' autofocus film bodies out there simply cannot find a home. Sometimes we want 'machines' to conform to our inherent way of thinking. - David Lyga
 

blansky

Member
Joined
Nov 6, 2002
Messages
5,952
Location
Wine country, N. Cal.
Format
Medium Format

OR, throw off the shackles of process and concentrate and enjoy "photography" or whatever you wish to call it, where the goal is not process and equipment but instead the final product.....the print. And not just the print, but the subject of the print.

And even further to that treat the process as tools. And create art with whatever tools are available to you.

Because the tools have and always will change.
 

blockend

Member
Joined
Aug 16, 2010
Messages
5,049
Location
northern eng
Format
35mm
True.
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…