DIY silver recovery on the cheap

BHuij

Member
Joined
Oct 12, 2016
Messages
887
Location
Utah
Format
Multi Format
I know this question has been asked before, so I'll try to be specific and provide all relevant details.

My goal here is to recover small quantities of silver from my B&W film and paper fixer (TF-5) to provide to my friend who casts semiprecious metals and creates custom jewelry, so he can make me a few pieces. To that end, I'm not terribly concerned with the economics, the efficiency, the purity of the final result, or anything like that. I just think it would be cool to wear a ring made out of silver from my own darkroom, and that would only take a few grams.

In my research so far, I stumbled on this article: http://analoguephotolab.com/silver-extraction-from-exhausted-film-fixer/

Makes it seem like it might be as simple as taking my exhausted TF-5, adjusting pH to 6 with some acid or (rather alkaline) tap water as needed, and tossing in some non-stainless steel wool for a few days. Then filter the liquid through coffee filters, let them dry, burn them, and hit the ash with a torch in a crucible to get at the metallic silver left behind. Possibly with some addition of borax and/or washing soda, though I'm unclear on what exactly those do to help the process along.

1. Has anyone tried this who can confirm it works (or definitely doesn't work)?
2. Is a regular propane torch hot enough to melt the metallic silver in the ash?
3. What grade of steel wool would work best?
4. How long should I expect to need to leave the wool in the fixer before it's diminishing returns on how much silver I recover?
 

MarkS

Member
Joined
Mar 12, 2004
Messages
507
That's a lot of effort to gain what will likely be a very small weight of silver.
 

Dirb9

Member
Joined
Mar 19, 2006
Messages
154
Format
Multi Format
Did that many years ago in high school, as the photography room was adjoining the jewellery metals area, and I thought it would be a fun experiment. Finer grade steel wool allows for more surface area exposed to the fix. I used 3 or 4 balls of steel wool in a gallon of fix, left it for about a week. A propane torch worked to get most of the steel wool burnt off, but I did end up needing to finish off with an oxy-acetylene torch. Oxy-propane may get you close enough, but I don't think a plain propane torch will get hot enough. Borax (flux) helps bring impurities out together so they can be burned off or removed as slag.

In that experiment, I recovered about 10 grams of silver. My teacher pointed out that I used probably about $5 of consumables to recover a couple bucks of silver. Fixer is considered exhausted anywhere between 2-10 grams/liter, depending on whether it's being used for color or b&w, paper or film, etc.
 
OP
OP

BHuij

Member
Joined
Oct 12, 2016
Messages
887
Location
Utah
Format
Multi Format
10g/gallon is pretty in line with what I would expect from my reading. A single 10g piece of silver would be enough to make the ring I have in mind.

I'm getting conflicting reports on what's actually happening while steel wool soaks in the fixer. Some places seem to say that the silver is attracted to the steel wool and plates it. Some say that the iron goes into solution, forcing the silver out of solution, so the silver is in the liquid you pour off, not attached to the steel wool (which would itself have a much higher melting point than silver, right?)

The guide I linked in the original post seems to indicate that you would want to pour the liquid through coffee filters to strain out the tiny pieces of metallic silver. It doesn't mention what happens to the steel wool you used.

Can anyone clarify?
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…