Discussing a ****** photograph

catem · Aug 4, 2006

Jim Chinn said:
I agree. I can't make others ask but if I want to use an APUG member image I will ask permission.

Could we not simply stipulate that permission has to be obtained first?

I have no objection to discussing other members' work at all, but I don't think I would want it to turn into mostly members' work, as there is already some space for that in the galleries.
Cate

philldresser · Aug 4, 2006

Jim

If you had made this a poll then I would vote yes. I love seeing how different people interpret an image in multiple ways. The previous examples have been a great examples of open forum discussion.

Phill

Michel Hardy-Vallée · Aug 4, 2006

Jim Chinn said:
I agree. I can't make others ask but if I want to use an APUG member image I will ask permission.

I think this would be the right thing to do; this could boost the popularity of the critique gallery.

Jim Chinn · Aug 4, 2006

Ok, Apug members images are fine, but you must get permission from that person as I consider this forum seperate from the intent they had when they orginally posted an image to any of the regular galleries.

I don't think it will skew to APUG images. We got a pretty eclectic bunch of folks interested to start and as others rotate in and out I think we will have a nice mix of images from classics to unknowns.

We will be adding new images every 3 days or so. Various images will generate different levels of discussion. Some may produce few posts others dozens. But I think the forum will generate a lot of visits and get others thinking about how they look at and think about photographs.

df cardwell · Aug 4, 2006

I'm in Jim..

don

Jim Chinn · Aug 4, 2006

A quick correction. Sean is going to set us up as a sub-forum under Members Organized Functions.

c6h6o3 · Sep 14, 2006

Jim Chinn said:
I would simply ask that you post a new thread each time in the Photographers Forum and title it with the format Discuss a (photographers name) photograph..

What ever the number of people, we will simply keep going rotating through the list.

What do you think?

I think that you're not rotating through any kind of list. Is this a regulated process or just a big free-for-all? If it's the latter, then I'd like to post one.

Jim Chinn · Sep 15, 2006

I was going to have a list of folks who wanted to put up an image and rotate through it so there would regularly be an image under consideration but there is enough people who post out of the blue that it is not needed.

So if you want to post one go for it.

Also thanks to everyone who has either posted an image or contributed to the discussions. I have discovered some new photographers along the way and some new perspectives on others as well.

severian · Sep 15, 2006

How

How do you post an image? Yes i'm serious!

the unnamed,anonymous, hidden, somewhat embarressed, truly tecnically challenged, embarressment to his son, yet willing to be a team player photographer, its easier to remember if you just think- UAHSETTCTPP

EASmithV · Dec 5, 2008

a what?

f/stopblues · Dec 5, 2008

He might have forgotten by now. He wrote that 2 years and 3 months ago ;-)

Discussing a ****** photograph

Membership Council

Privacy & Transparency

Privacy & Transparency