Wouldn't you need different formulae at least for different types of developers, because they work differently? Just as an example, aside from the type of developing agent, some developers are formulated with much more preservative and or accelerator than others. So dilution affects activity differently, potentially requiring materially different adjustments to time/agitation.
This was discussed before, and the conclusion was that this cannot be done easily to satisfaction. You are better of sticking to a couple dilutions and test them at different development times. Then, change the development time to get the desired gradient. Dilution is not a very practical variable, development time is.
That is in general (for Rodinal) halving the concentration doubles the dev time. Again, that would be a ballpark approximation.
Reply to (titrisol) from Dick Dickerson and Silvia Zawadzki (inventors of Xtol) of Kodak on the question of extending development times with increased dilution of developers.
Your comments about a rule of thumb got us to exploring some old data - some very extensive with Xtol, limited with D-76 and Microdol-X. There is a pattern of sorts. Diluting 1:1 typically adds 40% to the time. 1:2 adds 80% (relative to the undiluted time). 1:3 adds 120% - like tack on 40% for each successive dilution. There is noise around these generalizations, more so as dilution increases, but they would be useful figures to get a person in the ballpark. On the other hand, these generalizations fail miserably with T-Max developer, so it doesn't seem there is any broadly applicable rule of thumb that's safe.
Interesting question all the same. Thanks for sharing!
Dick & Silvia
For Rodinal I found that you have to change of the developing time by a factor of 1.13 for every degree.
I don't know how it compares, but the following equation works well for D23, D76 and ID11 when a temperature coefficient (c=2.5) is used:
t2 = t1*c^((T1-T2)/10)
Is there a general mathematical relationship to dev time and concentration like there is for temperature and dev time?
Not really. A big determiner is agitation, a huge topic of its own. But agitation directly effects the diffusion of developer through the emulsion, and the diffusion of development products back out through the emulsion. The OP is a chemist; he/she can probably already see where this is going.
In general (let's say that again -- *in general*), for continuous agitation, development time varies as the square root of dilution, all other things being equal. For example, if your normal time is 5 minutes, and you triple dilution, your new time is (5)(sqrt(3)) = 8.7 minutes.
For intermittent agitation (like inversion agitation with small tanks) the general rule of thumb is that development time varies directly with dilution. For example, if you double your dilution you double your time.
For stand and semi-stand development, all bets are off. Testing is the only way to find out.
Clearly, all this does is get you to a place to start testing. To nail it, you have to test your personal work flow. No other way really.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?