Roger Hicks said:Looks like lousy hole-trapping, with those numbers.
kaiyen said:Ole,
That thread seems to just talk about reciprocity failure in general. Perhaps the attachment to the first post says something useful about fomapan 200 in particular, but my membership hasn't been approved yet so I can't read it. Is Europan 200 the same as fomapan 200?
I'll wait until I can see the chart, I guess. But it seems like the two of you are saying that, at least with fomapan 200, the 35mm and 120 are the same, but both are different than sheet film.
Sigh.
allan
Ryuji said:Creation of hole traps is one effective way to deal with reciprocity failure but it doesn't have to be that. In the case of Foma emulsions, they could do more basic improvements first. Their films use coarser grains that are suboptimally sensitized, which can result in poor LIRF. Look at the MTF. At some 27lp/mm or so the MTF drops to 0.5. Tri-X crosses the same 50% MTF line at 55lp/mm, and T-MAX P3200 at 90lp/mm. This is not just lousy hole trapping.
I've never heard (read) the term hole-tapping, what does it mean?Roger Hicks said:Looks like lousy hole-trapping, with those numbers.
Cheers,
R.
Roger Hicks said:When an electron (negative charge) is knocked out by a photon, it leaves a 'positive hole'. If the 'positive hole' is refilled by another electron (or the same one, insofar as that means anything), the development site weakens or disappears. 'Trapping' the 'positive hole' increases sensitivity and decreases reciprocity failure.
May I suggest Fuji Acros 100? It's a great film for night shooting.kaiyen said:So...basically...the riduclous reciprocity failure recommendations from Foma are correct.
Wow. 10s>90s. That's already, what, almost a 4+ stop increase (depending on how you count stops). Wow.
Need to get some other film, I guess. I work in low light often enough that that kind of failure is not acceptable.
allan
hello, i use http://www.pinhole.cz/en/pinholedesigner/ to determine my foma 100 reciprocity. it works perfect. foma has terrible reciprocity numbers, but it is a great film. as i say i use it mostly in 4x5 pinholes so i am always shooting 47sec and looonnnggggerrrrrr mostly in the 5 min and 9 min range. as a result i am begining to shoot some t max 100. for t max i am in the 9 sec to 3 min range. a heck of a difference. now if i was using a lens foma would be fine for me.....but you can see i am working with ridiculous times when compared to most lens shots. i hope this helps.kaiyen said:Hi all,
I want to figure out the reciprocity behavior for Foma 200, which is what I use in 5x7. The numbers on the Foma page are ridiculous. Like 6 stops when you meter to 1s. Something crazy like that. Now, I can't go shooting sheets like crazy figuring it out, so I"d likely use 120 or even 35mm.
allan
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?