Brian,
I do not use Xtol for sheet, but HC110.
As I use Jobo 2521 tank by inversion (like a 135 Paterson tank) I need about 1.45 l of chemistry to properly cover the sheets. So my situation is like yours.
I've started, one day I had a lot of film to process, to re-use the working strengt HC110 and this proved very good. Beware of exhaustion, HC110 in dilution H (1+63) is good for 15 sheet of 4x5 if the volume is 1.45 liter chemistry.
Of course, you can't keep the chemistry over night.
Just my 2 c