Ian;
All of the blixes that we tried were fresh mixes and used one time only for the film in question. We exposed sensitometric strips from dmin to dmax and measured the density and the retained silver.
We also measured sharpness, grain and leuco dye formation.
Color reproduction studies were done with undercut and double undercut images.
None of the blixes that we made, when used fresh, made the cut except for the ones in the patent. I see none today that offer anything new. They are all either ammonium or sodium ferric EDTA and sodium or ammonium hypo at a pH of about 6.5.
There was, at that stage, no consideration of deep tank use, roller transport or anything including cost. That came later when every possible approach came under review. So, while I appreciate the comment and understand it, you are looking at it backwards from the way we actually did the R&D.
I really do wish there was a good blix out there, but they all follow the same pattern. I have had samples of all of them including many now defunct versions. I have the original Agfa paper blix here in a packet unopened left over from early experimentation, and I just disposed of two Japanese blixes by using them for color paper, but not film.
I used to get samples of these from everywhere and everyone. All got tested for paper and film, but not in seasoned or mechanical processes as you mention. Only if they survived this first cut did they go on for machine testing. They were all compared to our own blixes and bleach then fix technology for image quality.
If any passed our test, they went to Photographic Technology for testing in the continuous machines to see how they survived in a real world situation. Most all that got through the first cut failed there. We then had to fall back to the bleach then fix situation.
I have reams of patents on bleaches and blixes and stll remember some of the hallmark numbers such as BP 991,412. ( I think I got that right)
We also studied patents on removing metals from ores to see if there was any technology there. There was, but it would not work in film. We even had special chemicals synthesized, and just before his death, Keith Stephen was working on a new silver halide solvent that might have done the job.
As far as bleaches go, we worked with quinone, persulfate, Ferric ammonium citrate and chloride, copper salts and etc. None worked well either as a bleaching or blixing agent for one reason or another.
So, the best amateur C41 kits are nothing more than things I saw over 30 years ago. I stand by this. I see nothing new here, truly I do not.
PE