Apples & Oranges

A colleague sent me a link to a site called Apples & Oranges
It seems to be a place that collates & summarises articles comparing digital & traditional photography along with a link to the original. Seems like a good idea if you want to keep track of that debate particularly as there seems to be a more thoughtful swing back in favour of traditional processes these days. Might also be a good place to direct any confused photographers who are not sure which way they want to go.

The one by Erwin Puts is very good food for thought, but I can not at all say I completely agree...but then who the heck am I.

The article about "Real World test between Kodak Gold and Nikon D60 Dynamic range" has as many holes in it as a screen door. The "test" is not done well for the film or the DSLR. I mean hell, the film scan had more noise than my cheap P&S digi cam. Also the inability to get a properly exposed image from the Nikon D60 was a result of user ignorance, not a fault of the camera. The whole thing was just pointless and proved nothing for either medium.

Calumet spills the beans? I must have missed it, didn't see any "beans".

I have read some stuff from Kirk Tuck before and find his change from film to digital and back to film to be very interesting. Good to hear from someone who knows and understands both.

Jason

BTW, thanks for the link...

Jason