I'd really like to hear from users who have tried these formulas, Comparisons with results from the official chemistry as well as third-party kits, would be great.
I have. Actually, these are the only E6 chemicals I've ever used, so I can't compare them to any kits or official chemicals. Anyway, I first mixed the formulae from
post #1, the ones under "RECEIPT I , base reciept". The film I developed included gray card shots at -2, -1, 0, +1 and +2 stops. The result was quite bluish, but not terrible. I tried adjusting the potassium iodide content and even doubled it. It didn't seem to make any difference, which got me puzzled. Then I thought about trying the formulae of
post #14, which should be revised/improved. I didn't have any ethylenediamine, so I actually mixed just the FD from post #14, but mixed another batch of the CD from post #1. By the way, I also substituted Potassium Carbonate with the equimolar amount of Sodium Carbonate. Anyway, the pH of the FD was correct from the beginning, but the CD was way off. I wasn't entirely sure what the problem was, my cheap pH meter could be problematic, so I used it as is. The result was that the grayscale was better with this combination, but this time it had a green cast. This suggests that the pH of the CD was too low, something that my pH meter hinted at. This probably isn't related to the formula itself, but rather the
impure nature of some of my chemicals (CD specific, could be CD3, or citrazinic acid?). I made a correction with some NaOH solution and made another attempt. This time, I had an almost perfect grayscale and the slides looked fine.
So, the bottom-line is that these are viable formulae, but mixing a correct solution can be tricky.