Stac Pollaidh Rectangular

I like the cropped image better. For some reason it gives me a more 3D sensation like I am flying. I think it is because without so much sky the rock in the foreground is more powerful yet there is still enough sky to make me feel I am up in the air. I think some people might like it cropped even more like a panorama but to me the feeling of flying would be gone.
Dennis

I like this one slightly better - but they are both good

Martin

I prefer the square version. I like the dark sky top left in the square version

M