I'd say I preferred this one, but I guess that's just a personal thing. What puzzles me a bit is that you've not mentioned film speed or developer dilution/agitation, so I'm not so sure what you're intending to say here?
Good point. I posted these to go along with a thread about me trying out Rodinal for the first time but that's certainly not obvious from the gallery perspective.
The FP4+ was 1+25 for 6 minutes
The TXP320 was 1+50 for 15 minutes
Both were agitated the first 30 seconds, then for 10 seconds at the top of every minute thereafter.
I really like the look of the FP4+ as well. The 320TXP is a new film to me and I'm still getting used to it. Thanks for your input. Regards, Clifton