I like the tight composition of this closer perspective, but it feels less emotional than version 1, tho I cant explain why Id be interested in what any of you viewers thought
The feeling I get with this version, is one of safety, or familiarity, i.e. in the middle of somewhere, with lots going on. Whereas, with version 1, there is a feeling of isolation, which draws me more to that one emotionally.
I would also vote for this one. In my opinion, your composition brings the viewer right into the activity, and also provides a great sense of what it's like to be there. The other image, however seems to be too far away, if that is the best way to put it.