While this is another example of your fine workmanship, I think the #1 holds more interest with the composition. The reflections are interesting but I think secondary to the greater tree splendor. Perhaps in keeping with the shore line, a landscape composition would also work.My 2 cents.
Thank you, Bruce, and Shawn. You both make good points, and I'm not sure I have a favorite of the two. Sometimes I have to live with an image for a while to decide its worth.