WalkAlone

• 

  dried_squid

• Oct 12, 2008

The light falling on the water fountain man, the mystery escalator shaft (?), and the askew geometry of the roof snap for me. I like it.

It occurs to me that the people, moving or not, really make this. The framing and contrasting textures are great, but the people add some special sauce.

 

• 

  Bertus

• Oct 13, 2008

Great streetlife photo. The escalatorshaft in the middle is a nice and mystery element. I love the contrast too.

- Bert

 

• 

  danphoto_

• Oct 13, 2008

Thank you dried_squid and Bertus.
Although I would like you to tell me, if you were to change anything, what would that be ?!



danphoto_

 

• Uhner

• Oct 13, 2008

It is a good shot. I like the composition and how you captured how people move. But, I do find the contrast to be a bit on the harsh side.

 

• 

  danphoto_

• Oct 13, 2008

So, less contrast ? Thanks for the comment in advance Uhner.

 

• 

  michael9793

• Oct 13, 2008

Great job, don't change the contrast, anything less would make this a bla photo

mike a

 

• 

  Vincent Brady

• Oct 13, 2008

I would agree with Uhner that the contrast is rather harsh. I would also be prepared to crop off top of the photo so as to remove that skylight in the middle. I would also be inclined to crop off that LHS where that tiny portion of the outside roof can be viewed - its pulls the viewers eye over there.

Cheers
TEX

 

• 

  dried_squid

• Oct 13, 2008

As I see it on my display 1440 x 900, I wouldn't change it.

I would consider change with respect to size and presentation. For paper and 8 x 10 and up, I think the "light at the end of the tunnel" feeling might work. For paper and smaller than 8 x 10, perhap more gradation and less black surround might work better.

But if it was my picture, I would not change anything, and only present it as an 8 x 10 or 8 x 12 or larger.