St. Oliver Plunkett's Church

• 

  Thomas Bertilsson

• Feb 12, 2008

Like the toned one better. But they're both brilliant.
- Thomas

 

• Doug Webb

• Feb 12, 2008

I like them both, maybe the toned one a little more, but I always seem to like toned images. What a great location and great composition.
Doug Webb

 

• 

  Alden

• Feb 12, 2008

I prefer this one. IR and sepia is too much stuff. It's got an initial punch, but this draws me in, where the sepia pushes me away. Too much surface appeal defeats the subject content, IMO.

 

• pentaxuser

• Feb 12, 2008

It's a very close run thing. I keep on switching back and forth to come to a decision but can't.

pentaxuser

 

• 

  thefizz

• Feb 12, 2008

Thanks everyone, your views are much appreciated.

 

• 

  Shawn Dougherty

• Feb 12, 2008

I much prefer this version. Very well done, lots of impact.

 

• 

  Christopher Walrath

• Feb 12, 2008

I love this image alot. It's in my favs. Nice work.

 

• 

  thefizz

• Feb 13, 2008

Thanks for your comments Shawn & Christopher.

 

• moouers

• Jan 11, 2010

This image is a fascinating journey for me. Your choice of film is just perfect for this subject...great job.

Oh, and I prefer this straight B&W version more. Much more.