Liberty...Which one?

• 

  ajmiller

• Sep 11, 2010

This one for me though it's interesting how each of the three treatments bring a different 'feel' and interpretation to the photograph.

Tony

 

• 

  mooseontheloose

• Sep 11, 2010

I think this one! (although they're all good). This reminds me of a pencil sketch, or even a photo from an old newspaper (I mean that in a good way). It seems a little more ambiguous in interpretation.

 

• 

  Bertus

• Sep 11, 2010

This one is great, special the atmosphere and color.

- Bert

 

• 

  bdial

• Sep 11, 2010

I like this one. I like that there is more tone in the clouds around Miss Liberty, and the more open shadows.
I think it gives a better sense of place than the others.

 

• 

  stradibarrius

• Sep 11, 2010

this is my second choice.

 

• 

  ishutteratthethought

• Sep 11, 2010

so surreal .......perfect!

 

• 

  MaximusM3

• Sep 11, 2010

This is a real tough one, Vic...I'll take all three
Really, all are gorgeous...just different. This may be my favorite but it's a very close call for me.

 

• dennisl

• Sep 11, 2010

This is the one, probably because it holds detail better than the other two. Really like the way the photo progresses from the crowd, to the statue, to the sky. Great shot!

 

• 

  Shawn Dougherty

• Sep 11, 2010

This is it for me, I like the soft glow and shadow detail - FEELS more like a rainy day than the other two. Great work!

 

• 

  Dan Henderson

• Sep 11, 2010

Vic: the subject is perfect in all versions, especially today. But I do prefer this one more. The diffusion gives it a timeless feel. Well done.
Dan