Carmichael Grape Stump

• 

  Paul Cocklin

• Mar 15, 2010

Make the print! Very cool shot, love the low contrast foggy background with the stump; really gives an added dimension to the shot. Love it!

 

• 

  Marco B

• Mar 15, 2010

Yes, go for it. The atmosphere is really nice, and the stumps are just incredible. They look like the Ents of The Lord of the Rings marching down the field... ;-)

 

• 

  darinwc

• Mar 15, 2010

can't wait til I get my enlarger working!

 

• 

  Anscojohn

• Mar 15, 2010

Great potential. Were it mine, I would crop at the bottom to make the front stump a more forceful focal point at the beginng, then (as others have stated) the picture fading off into the mist. Great stuff.

 

• 

  martinhughesireland

• Mar 15, 2010

I like the composition, id print it..

 

• 

  Vincent Brady

• Mar 15, 2010

I would have some reservations regarding the composition. I would like not to have included the house in the background, but perhaps it was unavoidable. I feel you should have moved your position so as to isolate the stump in the foreground from those behind it. The atmosphere captured however is the strongest aspect to the photo, so therefore I would be inclined to print it.

 

• 

  Dan Henderson

• Mar 16, 2010

I have to agree with Tex. The composition would be so very much stronger if there were nothing but fog behind the grouping of tree trunks.