Thread for List of Suggested Cameras? (MF/otherwise)

Mustang

A
Mustang

  • 0
  • 0
  • 67
32nd Avenue

A
32nd Avenue

  • 0
  • 0
  • 69
Saab

A
Saab

  • 0
  • 0
  • 74
Chevy Van

A
Chevy Van

  • 1
  • 0
  • 72

Recent Classifieds

Forum statistics

Threads
182,067
Messages
2,519,713
Members
95,488
Latest member
Crit-ter85
Recent bookmarks
0

analoguey

Member
Joined
Jul 24, 2013
Messages
1,103
Location
Bangalore, I
Shooter
Multi Format
Wonder if it's a good idea to make a list of suggested or a Poll of suggested cameras/systems from APUG members. Considering that there seem to be enough people wanting to move into film/up to MF or large format etc.,? Sure each new thread allows to add in a post or two, but seems to me like it will save more forum space if camera reccos were captured in a more tabular manner or so? Or even a pie chart.

Probably a more "central" reservoir of the wealth of APUG knowledge at least on suggested cameras for suggested uses.


/Should this go under site suggestions?
 

Two23

Member
Joined
Jul 4, 2010
Messages
613
Location
South Dakota
Shooter
8x10 Format
There are so many types of cameras, and so many different interests. I mostly like cameras made between 1920 and 1950. Cameras from 1970-1990 are far more popular, but I have no interest in those at all. My favorite to use are the Leica IIIc, Rolleiflex, and the Voigtlander Bessa. These aren't as convenient to use as newer ones. I also love to shoot 4x5 but here again I rarely use modern lenses and prefer those from 1840s-1850s, or early 1900s. I only shoot b&w. There's a very wide range of interest and possibilities. Any "list" would have to get pretty specific.


Kent in SD
 
OP
OP
analoguey

analoguey

Member
Joined
Jul 24, 2013
Messages
1,103
Location
Bangalore, I
Shooter
Multi Format
Not really, Kent. It could even be a list of lists, or something that an Excel file could cook up.
something with options that could go like:

"Oh, long hike? less-heavy Medium Format shooter? Limited lens combos?... here you go, get X camera by 8 APUG users and get Y camera by 6 APUG users."

A few such shortlists and soon, most new system/camera seekers would have a ready reckoner.
 

bernard_L

Member
Joined
Feb 17, 2008
Messages
1,445
Shooter
Multi Format
Too many parameters. And to some large degree subjective. With the same requirements, each individual will make different choices, based on cost, weight, optical quality (real or carried by the internet rumor), need for flexibility, real or perceived need for film area to reach "adequate" quality, etc, etc. You can get useful information by reading in threads not which camera is "best" for a given purpose, but why this or that user prefers this or that system, and filtering through your own needs and preferences. A little like movie critics: there is not a single one whose advice you agree 100% of the time. And a movie seat costs less than a camera.
 

BrianShaw

Member
Joined
Nov 30, 2005
Messages
13,494
Location
Here or there.
Shooter
Multi Format
Show me the table (or the pie) variables and I'll contribute my 2-cents worth.
 
Joined
Oct 29, 2006
Messages
4,796
Location
İstanbul
Shooter
35mm RF
To have a good, old or classic camera does not make you a good photographer. Some guys go to trip to europe with several thousands dollars worth of m7 and shoot on expired fuji film. There are people gives 400 dollars or more to a 8X10 pinhole camera. I learned that there is only 10 or less good photographer in APUG to be considered serious. If you want lists of lists , we have gallery and with searching a film , camera , paper , you find whom used what.
 

Alan W

Member
Joined
May 16, 2009
Messages
545
Location
Tennessee
Shooter
Medium Format
To have a good, old or classic camera does not make you a good photographer. Some guys go to trip to europe with several thousands dollars worth of m7 and shoot on expired fuji film. There are people gives 400 dollars or more to a 8X10 pinhole camera. I learned that there is only 10 or less good photographer in APUG to be considered serious. If you want lists of lists , we have gallery and with searching a film , camera , paper , you find whom used what.

Maybe the 10,or less, good photographers can give the O.P. their opinion.
 

Dali

Member
Joined
Jun 17, 2009
Messages
1,660
Location
Philadelphia
Shooter
Multi Format
Wonder if it's a good idea to make a list of suggested or a Poll of suggested cameras/systems from APUG members. Considering that there seem to be enough people wanting to move into film/up to MF or large format etc.,? Sure each new thread allows to add in a post or two, but seems to me like it will save more forum space if camera reccos were captured in a more tabular manner or so? Or even a pie chart.

Probably a more "central" reservoir of the wealth of APUG knowledge at least on suggested cameras for suggested uses.


/Should this go under site suggestions?

What do you prefer? reading posts or staring at a pie chart?
 

Dali

Member
Joined
Jun 17, 2009
Messages
1,660
Location
Philadelphia
Shooter
Multi Format
"To have a good, old or classic camera does not make you a good photographer. Some guys go to trip to europe with several thousands dollars worth of m7 and shoot on expired fuji film. There are people gives 400 dollars or more to a 8X10 pinhole camera. I learned that there is only 10 or less good photographer in APUG to be considered serious. If you want lists of lists , we have gallery and with searching a film , camera , paper , you find whom used what."

I wonder where does the OP make reference to a "good" photographer or a "serious" one, to paraphrase you, unless you know better than the OP what he meant...
 
OP
OP
analoguey

analoguey

Member
Joined
Jul 24, 2013
Messages
1,103
Location
Bangalore, I
Shooter
Multi Format
Too many parameters. And to some large degree subjective. With the same requirements, each individual will make different choices, based on cost, weight, optical quality (real or carried by the internet rumor), need for flexibility, real or perceived need for film area to reach "adequate" quality, etc, etc. You can get useful information by reading in threads not which camera is "best" for a given purpose, but why this or that user prefers this or that system, and filtering through your own needs and preferences. A little like movie critics: there is not a single one whose advice you agree 100% of the time. And a movie seat costs less than a camera.

Agreed on the parameters, but again, might be a good way to get the information out there.
My idea is not on ridiculing the thread format or on anyone asking questions, but on "archiving" (loosely put) the information that APUG users richly have and provide in an easy to access format. Again, I agree with the reviews, I have some personal likings someone else the opposite - but its not that hard to capture it really. (Maybe my background in using spreadsheets for inane comparisons- work related- and lists helps me that way..:D)

The key idea was/is to capture the information in one place.
 
Joined
Mar 18, 2005
Messages
4,945
Location
Monroe, WA, USA
Shooter
Multi Format
OP
OP
analoguey

analoguey

Member
Joined
Jul 24, 2013
Messages
1,103
Location
Bangalore, I
Shooter
Multi Format
To have a good, old or classic camera does not make you a good photographer.
Sorry, that wasnt my question at all. And mind you, this is the equipment forum :smile:



What do you prefer? reading posts or staring at a pie chart?
Could be an app or a single thread. Idea was just information collation and presentation. :smile:
Reading posts can be quite confusing even at the end of all the reading (as can pie charts!)
 
Last edited by a moderator:

David Brown

Member
Joined
Feb 16, 2004
Messages
3,986
Location
Earth
Shooter
Multi Format
OK, getting back to the OP question; I don't think this is really answerable, but I'll play:

645 fixed lens: Fuji rangefinders

645 interchangeable lenses: Mamiya/Pentax/Bronica

6x6 rangefinder : Mamiya 6

6x6 TLR fixed lens: Rolleiflex, Minolta Autocord

6x6 TLR interchangeable lenses: Mamiya

6x6 SLR: Hasselblad, Bronica, Rolleiflex

6x6 “budget”: Yashica TLR, Kowa 6

6x7 fixed lens: Fuji 670

6x7 interchangeable lens rangefinder: Mamiya 7

6x7 SLR: Pentax 67, Mamiya RB/RZ67, Bronica

6x9 fixed lens: Fuji 690

6x9 “press”: Mamiya Press, baby Graflex

6x9 view camera: any view camera with a roll film back

... let the games begin! :cool:
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Joined
Jan 14, 2003
Messages
4,925
Location
San Francisco
Shooter
Multi Format
OK, getting back to the OP question; I don't think this is really answerable, but I'll play:

645 fixed lens: Fuji rangefinders

645 interchangeable lenses: Mamiya/Pentax/Bronica

6x6 rangefinder : Mamiya 6

6x6 TLR: Rolleiflex, Minolta Autocord

6x6 SLR: Hasselblad, Bronica

6x6 “budget”: Yashica TLR, Kowa 6

6x7 fixed lens: Fuji 670

6x7 interchangeable lens rangefinder: Mamiya 7

6x7 SLR: Pentax 67, Mamiya RB/RZ67, Bronica

6x9 fixed lens: Fuji 690

6x9 “press”: Mamiya Press, baby Graflex

6x9 view camera: any view camera with a roll film back

... let the games begin! :cool:

Yes! Just append one:

6x6 SLR: Hasselblad, Bronica, ROLLEIFLEX (SL66 and related)
 

TareqPhoto

Member
Joined
Nov 19, 2009
Messages
1,171
Location
Ajman - UAE
Shooter
Multi Format
OK, getting back to the OP question; I don't think this is really answerable, but I'll play:

645 fixed lens: Fuji rangefinders

645 interchangeable lenses: Mamiya/Pentax/Bronica

6x6 rangefinder : Mamiya 6

6x6 TLR: Rolleiflex, Minolta Autocord

6x6 SLR: Hasselblad, Bronica

6x6 “budget”: Yashica TLR, Kowa 6

6x7 fixed lens: Fuji 670

6x7 interchangeable lens rangefinder: Mamiya 7

6x7 SLR: Pentax 67, Mamiya RB/RZ67, Bronica

6x9 fixed lens: Fuji 690

6x9 “press”: Mamiya Press, baby Graflex

6x9 view camera: any view camera with a roll film back

... let the games begin! :cool:

David, this is a good start, and if each add something then we can have that thread which can be a good reference, sure it will not stop posting threads for new members, but it will help a lot in answers and even those new members may not start threads asking many questions after looking at that reference thread.

I suggest we start with one size format, then when we include most important things not necessary 100% details then we can move to another size format, let's start with 6x4.5 then 6x6 then 6x7,...etc.

In film field of MF i have only 6x6/6x7 and 6x9, i can contribute with what i have, but i am not an equipment expert, i sometimes come here to ask or find information about something i have or want to get.

How about first start by categorize the type of cameras in MF world, then we can put each type on different format sizes.
 

removed account4

Subscriber
Joined
Jun 21, 2003
Messages
29,850
Shooter
Hybrid
hi OP

as for large format ....

there are several branches of this sort of photography but here goes

anything "graphic or graflex "
( speed, crown view, viewII, slr &c )
is a workhorse and a great camera for most applications.

for olde timey sorts of things, there are box and magazine cameras
that will have simple lenses and shutters and be a bit more unpredictable than something
more modern. box cameras were made in all shapes and sizes, small roll films, large sheet films
and will usually give you a lo-fi lo-tech, atmospheric image like a modern lomo or holga or ?
for a fraction of the $$
 

Rick A

Subscriber
Joined
Mar 31, 2009
Messages
9,199
Location
Laurel Highlands
Shooter
Large Format
David, you failed to list Mamiya TLR's for 6x6.
 

David Brown

Member
Joined
Feb 16, 2004
Messages
3,986
Location
Earth
Shooter
Multi Format
David, you failed to list Mamiya TLR's for 6x6.

Doh! :confused:

I own and use one! Just goes to show how hard it is to make such a list ...

(List edited)
 

MattKing

Moderator
Moderator
Joined
Apr 24, 2005
Messages
41,648
Location
Delta, BC, Canada
Shooter
Multi Format
It is true, we do need another "deleted" thread:whistling:.

I think the challenge is that the format of the website isn't conducive to this.

An accumulating "polling" type format might be better.
 
Photrio.com contains affiliate links to products. We may receive a commission for purchases made through these links.
To read our full affiliate disclosure statement please click Here.

PHOTRIO PARTNERS EQUALLY FUNDING OUR COMMUNITY:



Ilford ADOX Freestyle Photographic Stearman Press Weldon Color Lab Blue Moon Camera & Machine
Top Bottom