Number one clearly is the best balanced print in my opinion. It appears that's the smaller version of what you posted earlier - which means I'm part of 'Joe Public'?
Interesting effect that selenium has on this process - one would normally expect it to intensify but it does not appear to have been the case - I could live with 1 or 3!
I think that after you look at them for awhile #1 stands out, but at first glance #3 draws the eye because it's lighter. Selenium toning #2 would have been interesting.
I prefer #1, warmer with a glow...but depends upon mood you want to portray, as #3 leaves you cold and impersonal (kind of a sterile look), which large churches can give that type of feeling...both physically and sometimes spiritually. #2 seems a little muddy to me on my screen...